Interface translated; public records are shown in their original language.
↑ Earlier in the sittingI am pleased to speak for a few minutes. I'm not sure exactly how much time I have left - five minutes or so - on this bill. Obviously, the topic of the bill is one that we spoke about many times on the floor of the Legislature, and I am sure it won't be the last time.
I do want to address some of the characterization from the members opposite - particularly the Leader of the Official Opposition - pertaining to our government's responsibility, and pointing fingers, and not dealing with issues that are on our desks. The fact of the matter is that we know there are a number of challenges that Nova Scotians are facing every day - whether it be the affordability crisis, whether it be the housing crisis - and we are not shying away, turning a blind eye or pointing fingers at previous governments.
We're accepting that we have a responsibility to act, and we are doing so. I think Budget 2024-25 speaks volumes to that, and speaks to our investments in Nova Scotians. It speaks to investments that we're making to build this province up, to build the housing that we need, to build the health care infrastructure that we need, to build the road infrastructure that we need. I could go on.
I believe my honourable colleague, the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing, the member for Kings North, has referenced many times deferred maintenance. Perhaps that is a little bit of finger-pointing to the previous governments, but that is the fact. There was a lot of deferred maintenance, and as the member opposite likes to say, issues that are on our desks, but I think some of them are perhaps issues that were left on their desks when they were ministers in previous governments. Again, we are not shying away from the fact that we have a lot of work ahead of ourselves.
The assertions that as a government - whether it's Progressive Conservative, NDP, Liberal, or any other stripe for that fact - we can control global, external factors, whether it be mortgage rates or inflation or supply chain issues or labour shortages, all realities that the construction industry is facing - that is completely ridiculous. I don't care what party is on this side of the aisle, no government is going to be able to control that. To insinuate that we can, I think we could debate that until we're blue in the face and perhaps the Opposition would ring some bells by doing so during that debate.
We are very happy to be here and that's one thing I will say . . .interruption .
Order. Order. You know, I think about my young fella's teacher. He says: Are you being your best selves today?Laughter I just ask in context if we could keep that in mind.
The honourable Minister for Service Nova Scotia and Internal Services.
Speaker, I'm not shying away from being here and doing the good work on behalf of the people of Nova Scotia with my colleagues on this side of the House. We were elected to govern. We were elected to serve our constituents and whether that's 9:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. or 12:00 noon to 12:00 midnight, so be it. We're here to do that work. There are a lot of hard-working Nova Scotians who go to work every single day who do shift work, and when their shift work is done, they go beyond that. Guess what? I'm not shying away from that. Been there, actually.
I think some of that deferred maintenance that my colleague spoke about, and the challenges that we're faced with today in the housing marketplace, were a failure to predict that Nova Scotia is a province of opportunity, a province of growth - growth that we're accepting. We are very fortunate to welcome newcomers to our province.
We are very fortunate that we have targeted supports to welcome these newcomers to our province and can be strategic in welcoming these people we need in Nova Scotia, whether it be skilled tradespeople or health care professionals. I could go on. We know that Nova Scotia needs people to build houses, schools, hospitals, and roadways. That's why we're getting it done.
We're not shying away from the responsibility ahead of us and that's in front of us right now. We'll continue to take the right steps forward to support Nova Scotians and to make investments in the people of this province. I have confidence in everyone on this side of the aisle, in my cabinet and caucus colleagues who support the work of our government. We're moving in the right direction.
Order. The time allotted for debate on this bill has elapsed. Pursuant to Rule No. 20(2), the debate is deemed to be adjourned.
The honourable Official Opposition House Leader.
Speaker, would you please call Bill No. 405 - HST Reduction Act.16:45
Bill No. 405 - HST Reduction Act.
The honourable member for Kings South.
I'm pleased to stand and speak on Bill No. 405, the HST Reduction Act.
My comments will first outline why we need tax relief in this province. Then I will speak a bit about debunking the government's position and claim that this budget provides tax relief. Then I'll speak about whether we can afford this and touch upon the increased revenues and the Auditor General's report that outlines clearly where so much money is going and moving off the books for Nova Scotians.
Why do we need tax relief? The Minister of Finance and Treasury Board has stated that this was the number one request during budget consultations. I think everyone in this House can agree with that. Nova Scotians are hurting. They are struggling. Affordability is top of mind to so many Nova Scotians. We've had large bumps in inflation these past three years at 4 per cent, 7.5 per cent, and 4.5 per cent. That's putting considerable pressure on Nova Scotians, both low- and middle-income.
The cost of housing: We talked about rent control not doing its job with rent increases of 19 per cent in Nova Scotia. Of course, Nova Scotians are finding it extremely difficult with food inflation and the ability to feed their families. That is exhibited through the very high use of our food banks and the growing lines. These are serious issues for Nova Scotians. They are looking to us as legislators - to this government - to provide some tax relief.
The other reason tax relief is necessary is for the competitiveness of our province. With the highest taxes in the country, it's very difficult for us to attract businesses and the employees who are going to work in those businesses to Nova Scotia. We have the highest provincial tax rates in the country.
We have the highest HST, and that's why we are proposing that we reduce the HST. The need for tax relief is there to support Nova Scotians and for our ability to compete across this country and this world for business. While we remain the highest-taxed jurisdiction in the country, we are losing ground.
I noticed in the budget this year that the budget has revised downward their estimates for GDP for this province. That should be a concern for government, a government that is on a freewheeling spending spree. It's easy to spend money when times are good, but you actually have to keep some money in the bank for when times are bad. This government is increasing debt and deficit and still punishing Nova Scotians with the highest taxes in the world while the government is receiving massive tax increases.
Let's talk a little bit about this budget and the claims by the Finance and Treasury Board Minister and the Premier of this province on the tax relief provided in this budget. The tax relief, if you talk about ending bracket creep - which we support as long overdue - is a total in this budget of $13 million. If we put that in the context of the budget showing that the government of Nova Scotia is going to take in $4.1 billion in personal taxes - $13.4 million, but it's actually not even providing tax relief. Ending bracket creep is not lowering taxes. It's removing a hidden tax increase. If you don't believe me, there have been several articles from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation and from the Fraser Institute recently published in response to this budget.
Many people don't understand bracket creep, and I certainly wonder whether our Premier understands bracket creep. For the Premier to talk about this as - the Premier's words were "This is an incredible form of tax relief for Nova Scotia, absolutely incredible. I personally believe it is the biggest." The biggest: $13.4 million of removing a hidden tax increase. It is now the biggest form of tax relief in the province, in history. The Minister of Finance and Treasury Board is quoted as saying "The number one ask by Nova Scotians in this year's budget consultation was for tax relief and they're going to get it." These two statements are completely false.
Let's hear from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, from February 29th : "Bracket creep happens when governments don't move tax brackets with inflation and inflation can automatically bump taxpayers into a higher tax bracket even though they can't actually afford to buy more. 'A bright spot for taxpayers is that Houston is finally ending the sneaky backdoor income tax hike known as bracket creep,' . . . 'Houston needs to cut spending, stop racking up red ink and provide taxpayers with further relief.'"
Order, please. I'm sorry, it doesn't matter. You're not allowed to use a person's name.
The honourable member for Kings South.
Thank you, Speaker. I was referring to the Premier, of course. My apologies.
Alex Whalen, the Associate Director of Atlantic Canada Prosperity at the Fraser Institute provided the following opinion article: "While it's certainly welcome news, it's not a tax cut. And it does not meaningfully change Nova Scotia's overall tax problem."
It goes on to say:
With this budget, the government had an opportunity to restrain spending and improve the province's finances and position itself for serious tax relief going forward. It failed to take advantage of that opportunity, which is the government's prerogative. However, trumpeting the 'largest tax cut in Nova Scotia's history' when it's neither historic nor a true tax cut is quite a stretch, particularly given that the true problem remains unsolved.
Why can we afford this? Personal income taxes in this province have gone up $1.2 billion in four years, 43 per cent. HST has gone up $850 million, or 45 per cent in four years. Commercial income tax, $340 million, or 82 per cent in four years. The government has received $1.1 billion more in equalization payments, an increase of 53 per cent from the federal government.
Total revenues for the Government of Nova Scotia in the last four years, including this upcoming budget, have increased 39 per cent - total revenues of $4.4 billion. And the government's on a spending spree. I know we'll hear all about the things that Nova Scotia wants, and we're spending the things on what Nova Scotia wants.
The Auditor General's report released yesterday gives us some very clear indication of where this money is going, and it's actually not going to projects this year. The March spending - the "March Madness" of this government, when they get their windfalls that they didn't anticipate, is to throw it out the door as quickly as they can in any way feasible, and try to run a deficit so that they can tell Nova Scotians that we're really working on all the problems that you care about.
The Auditor General has indicated that she only looked at $433 million of a billion dollars of additional appropriations last year. That billion dollars is four cents of HST. As much as $737 million - 86 per cent of that money out the door, taxpayers' money which this government gave to organizations across the province - has not been spent, 86 per cent of it. Some of them are for multi-year projects.
Why aren't we funding those in the year that we actually have to fund them? Instead, we're giving the money out the door in which the Auditor General has shown us that there were no strings - in some cases, no paper. Some universities didn't even know the money was coming and didn't have a project, but suddenly $25 million appeared. It's absolutely insane. We've lost millions of dollars of interest revenue. And what's interest revenue? We can't put that money on the debt. We have to pay interest.
For 11 out of the 11 projects, there was no immediate spending need for any of them, while Nova Scotians have a need for tax relief - real tax relief. The government has to stop chasing headlines, announcing projects that nobody's even thought of. Throw money out the door. Waste taxpayers' dollars. Continue to mount up massive debt. Because when times turn bad, then we'll be looking at our debt-to-GDP and saying, Oh, we can't do anything.
We found no evidence that these projects needed upfront funding. Fiscal capacity alone is a poor rationale to distribute public funds in advance of need. The words of the Auditor General - and what Nova Scotians should be really shocked and concerned about is this government's blatant disregard for the opinions of the Auditor General and disagreeing with the Auditor General.17:00
Nova Scotians need tax relief. There's an affordability crisis and this government wants to send out hundreds of millions of dollars to sit in somebody else's bank account while they struggle for food. That's why we've brought this bill in. A 2 per cent HST cut would return $500 million to Nova Scotians. I hope I have shown you Nova Scotians that a 2 per cent HST drop is affordable. Nova Scotians deserve tax relief and Bill No. 405 will provide that. I now move Bill No. 405.
Order. Second reading was moved last week. We will continue debate.
The honourable member for Dartmouth North.
I'm happy to get up and speak to this bill. I'm happy to speak about the issue of affordability in general. We know that so many Nova Scotians are feeling the pinch, feeling the crunch of the current cost of living crisis.
In Dartmouth North, which is the area I represent, for years we were known - predecessor the honourable Joanne Bernard was credited with saying this, and I agreed with her at the time - that Dartmouth North is No. 1 on the list of all the bad thingsinterruption was it Jerry Pye? - and last on the list of all the good things. I apologize to Joanne.
That is true, and that is why there has always been a significant look at Dartmouth North as an area of deep need. We have the highest percentage of people living in rental housing in Dartmouth North. We have the highest amount of people on income assistance in Dartmouth North. We have very little in the way of health services, although I think that's changing. It's supposed to be changing this year. What that means is since I've been elected, since 2017, my office is an extremely busy place. We meet people on a daily basis in our office who are struggling to make ends meet.
This is not the odd person who comes in - this is the usual. This is the norm. The unusual person is someone who comes in and asks for pins and flags because their kid is going to a tournament somewhere. That's the exception to the rule of who spends time in the Dartmouth North constituency office. Of course, my office is there to serve everyone, but I do want to say that I feel like speaking about the affordability crisis. As the person who has the privilege of representing the community of Dartmouth North, I feel like I've got some special insight into this topic.
I would go further, just in my intro here, to say that nowadays, with the current cost of living crisis, the folks who used to come into the office who were living on the edge - they were extremely vulnerable and came from a population that was extremely vulnerable, had often lived in precarious housing or were facing housing precarity, always had lived in poverty, and they had all kinds of reasons for coming in. Now I see people coming in for whom these issues and problems are new. That speaks to me and tells me that things have definitely changed.
I remember speaking - and I have referenced this time and time again - in July or August of 2019 or 2020, before the pandemic, when things started changing on the housing front in Dartmouth North and when people began to come in because they were getting evicted for no reason or they couldn't find a place to live. I said to my caucus colleagues at that time, Something is going on and it's going to get bad. It has continued to get worse. Now we see everyone - middle-class people and families with two parents or two adults working at good, well-paid jobs having trouble making ends meet too. They are worried about their power increases and about their cost of groceries.
This is now a crisis that is affecting so many more people. It has always been a crisis for lots of people, but the cost of essentials has been rapidly rising in this case in the last couple of years, on everything from power and food to fuel and housing. Everybody is now feeling the pinch. We know the cost of groceries has increased 6 per cent over the last year and 13 per cent over the year before. Last year's Food Banks Canada Report noted that 53 per cent of people in Nova Scotia feel that they are worse off than they were a year ago. This is a higher proportion than in any other province.
We also know the statistics about child poverty and about food insecurity. Power rates have increased 13.6 per cent in two years. Families all over the province are struggling to make ends meet. We agree - I've always agreed - that people need a break. That's why we're putting ideas forward, and that's why we have been putting these ideas forward for years - to help average Nova Scotians who are facing rising housing costs, food costs, and energy costs, with wages that just aren't keeping up.
Ideas like the one we recently announced, like removing unnecessary vehicle fees - the sticker on your license plate, for instance. My colleague, the Leader of the New Democratic Party, likes to say it's the most expensive sticker you'll ever buy and largely unnecessary.
Then we have older policies and older ideas that we've talked about. That reminds me. Before I go into this exhaustive list of suggestions, may I just reference for a moment our feisty and lively Question Period we had today, where the NDP was accused of being negative about everything and told we needed to be positive. I always thought that we do a pretty darn good job of being positive. In fact, I have made the joke over and over again that we are not just the Opposition but the proposition, because we like to make proposals and we have ideas - ideas like rent control.
My colleague eloquently spoke about a rent control system in Nova Scotia that would address the needs of renters while at the same time address the needs of landlords. Our piece of legislation on rent control allows for landlords to make application to raise a rent higher than whatever the CPI is if they can show that they need to because of renovations, floods, fires, or whatever. It does meet the needs of landlords and renters.
We also have called for - wait for it - a living wage. In Halifax, the living wage has now been determined to be $26 per hour. Workers in Halifax who are making minimum wage are making almost $11 less than that. That is untenable and makes things impossible. It makes it impossible to make ends meet.
We've also called for free birth control and menstrual products. Ding ding ding. Guess what, folks? The NDP in Ottawa is making that happen for us, which I'm very grateful about. But you know what? That's going to save a lot of people a lot of money every month.
Here's another idea: a low-income power rate. Well, guess what? We are currently debating a massive bill that will restructure the electricity system in Nova Scotia. If we don't take the opportunity to contemplate - at the very least, contemplate - a low-income power rate while we are debating this massive bill - pardon me: shoving it through the legislative process, Speaker - then we are doing all Nova Scotians a disservice. As I quoted the great Tracy Chapman last week: If we don't do it now, then when?
We could also ban power disconnections. That is also something that could be contemplated in a debate of that bill, of Bill No. 404, but I don't think it's going to happen.
We could expand the HomeWarming program - heat pumps and whatnot. Heat pumps save a heck of a lot of money, but a lot of people don't have them because it's expensive to put them in in the first place.
We in the Public Accounts Committee - sorry, the whole province - saw the Auditor General's report on over-budget spending yesterday and this morning, and there is a whack of money that Efficiency Nova Scotia has been given by the government to do programs. Listen, I love Efficiency Nova Scotia - let's make sure that people are able to access energy-efficient programs and instruments, whatever they're called - things that will make their power bills go down. If we can't get the rates to go down, we can at least get the bills to go down. Heat pumps for everyone. Insulation - I can't insulate my house because it's insulated with seaweed. It's a big problem. But most people can.
Let's change the building codes so that we make sure we're building warm, well-built, efficient homes in the first place to reduce people's costs. These are all great ideas that could help with the cost of living.
Oh, I know - eliminate Pharmacare co-payments. Universal food program. Speaker, before you call me out of order, I will reiterate that what I am doing here is suggesting some things that will bring down costs for Nova Scotians. This bill is calling for a reduction in HST. I'm suggesting other ways we can bring down costs for Nova Scotians. A universal school food program: check. We're getting that. The NDP has been calling for that for a long time. Increase and index the Affordable Living Tax Credit - that's a good idea.
How about a seniors' income benefit? Most provinces in this country have a seniors' income benefit. If you qualify for the OAS and the GIS - whatever it's called - then you automatically get a seniors' income benefit. Not in Nova Scotia. You get $750 one time. The other way would help seniors who are struggling to make ends meet in a much more predictable way, and a bit more money.
How about paid sick days? Good one. How about we stop tip theft and wage theft? People who are working in the service industry - the service economy, which is the underpinning of our tourism industry, by the way - sometimes they have to fight to keep their tips. If you are struggling to make ends meet, Speaker, you need to use your tips and keep your tips. Let's bring in legislation to stop tip theft. We could also index and increase the HARP.
While we do think that discussions about affordability need to talk about taxes - we do, and I'm back on the taxes, we need to make sure that the system is fair and works for Nova Scotia. That's why the NDP government eliminated HST on essential items like children's clothing, like groceries and diapers and books. We did that when we were in government, and we think it might be a good idea to axe any tax on items bought in the grocery store. We have proposed that as well.
Home heating: The Liberals were unsupportive of these tax-break measures. It wasn't long ago that Stephen McNeil voted against taking HST off power bills and home heating. In fact, the Liberals voted eight times to tax home heating and energy.
I think many Nova Scotians, like us, are skeptical of the big promises that the Liberals do make in Opposition. We've heard this before. Our friends in the government often point out the fact that the Liberal Party could have done lots of these things when they were in power for . . .interruption .
Order. Order. I ask that a little more self-control happen in the House. I understand the passion from the members, but please respect the person who is speaking.17:15
I'll ask the person speaking to please respect the bill that we are speaking about today. I understand, but your yo-yo is coming to the end of the string, and you don't haul it back fast enough, so please.
The honourable member for Dartmouth North.
Thank you, but actually I was talking about the bill specifically in this moment. This bill is suggesting that we cut the HST by 2 per cent. I was merely saying that when they were in government, the people who wrote this bill voted against cutting the HST from power bills and home heating costs.
I think, like many Nova Scotians, people are skeptical of these big ideas when they're in opposition. The Liberals have been promising a gas tax cut since 2009. Despite eight years in government, with the current Leader of the Liberal Party in Cabinet, this never happened. So why would Nova Scotians trust them on this idea?
I have so much more to say, Speaker. I will close by saying to take our ideas and make things better for Nova Scotians.