Interface translated; public records are shown in their original language.
↑ Earlier in the sittingIt's a pleasure to rise in my place to speak to Bill No. 412, Residential Tenancies Act (amended) respecting administration and enforcement.
I want to reassure all Nova Scotians and members of this House that our government is very well aware of the challenges being faced in our rental market. It has been debated over the past couple of days so far, and I'm sure we'll have plenty more opportunities to do so throughout the remainder of this sitting.
There are challenges being faced by both tenants and landlords. I think that's at least one thing that all three parties can agree on, after listening to feedback from the members opposite.
I know earlier I spoke about the requirement - the need for balance. I heard some mumblings and grumblings, and I won't point fingers at where those rumblings and grumblings may have come from, but it is the reality. It is the reality when we look at any element of the Residential Tenancies Program. The Residential Tenancies Program works. Apparently, there are folks in this Chamber who do not believe that it works but I want to reassure Nova Scotians that there are dedicated folks who work within my department who strive to do the best they can do to administer this program.
I'd highlight the fact that we were able to reduce hearing wait times. Back in September they were upwards of eight weeks, and now they're around four weeks, Speaker. That's due to the commitment and the hard work of the staff, some levers that we're pulling to make the administration of these hearings quicker, and also understanding - and I think it's fair to recognize - that there are instances where there are more egregious acts that may be committed by either a tenant or landlord, and we strive to do what we call an early adjournment so that those types of cases that are brought forward are addressed more quickly.
Again, the program is designed that it's reporting-based. Either a tenant or a landlord comes to the program and makes a complaint, submits an application to the program, and then it's heard. A little bit contrary to what's in the piece of legislation as presented by the member opposite about pretty much going out and patrolling for non-compliance. I don't think that's something that perhaps would be appropriate and furthermore the reference to police being involved in such a compliance and enforcement unit.
What has been said by members opposite pertaining to both tenants and landlords agreeing to a compliance and enforcement unit - yes, there has been mutual agreement from both parties that they agree that there needs to be, or they think there should be, a compliance and enforcement unit, but as I started to reference in a question during Question Period, or an answer during Question Period, and even some feedback received through my department, my understanding is that those groups perhaps have a misunderstanding of what a compliance and enforcement unit would achieve and that both tenant and landlord groups believe that a compliance and enforcement unit would result in the enforcement of directors' orders. That's not something that an enforcement unit does and it's not something that any other enforcement unit does in the country.
The member opposite said many other provinces or territories have this. In fact, there are only two, between Ontario and British Columbia, and that it's a simple fix. The reference that it's being a simple fix, I respectfully disagree with. There is nothing within the Residential Tenancies Program that could be perceived as a simple fix. We're dealing with, as the member opposite - my colleague from the Liberal party - spoke about, hundreds of thousands of tenants and thousands of landlords and they all have different scenarios and lived experiences and issues that they're dealing with and challenges that they're dealing with. Again, I do want to avoid the reference in this Chamber that all tenants are the same and all landlords are the same.15:15
I spoke earlier about some of the reasons why last Spring we amended in this House the Interim Residential Rental Increase Cap Act. It was previously 2 per cent. That is and continues to be a temporary solution as our government makes significant investments in housing. That is the solution to the housing crisis. We've heard references to a low vacancy rate in this province and I would argue, and perhaps agree with some members opposite, that the low vacancy rate being experienced in our province is having a negative impact on different elements of the Residential Tenancies Program.
That said, that's why, under the purview and leadership of the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing, we are taking action to build more than 40,000 new units over the next five years. The creation or the potential creation of a compliance and enforcement unit is not going to be the silver bullet for fixing a housing crisis. Those other provinces that I referenced earlier that have a compliance and enforcement unit, they are dealing with housing challenges as well. I think that is very important to recognize.
Speaker, we continue to engage. My department continues to engage with both tenant and landlord groups to hear their feedback. We are not sitting on our hands. Again, the first piece of legislation that I brought forward as Minister of Service Nova Scotia was amendments to this Act. I noted it before and I know members opposite have said it before as well - it's not a closed book, and it is not a closed book. The fact is that the marketplace, the landscape of housing, is ever-changing, based on unprecedented population growth.
We know there are challenges with population growth, but we are accepting those challenges because we know that there are opportunities and that's why there are cross-government efforts to address and work on solutions to address those opportunities to build up our province. The challenges we are experiencing today within Residential Tenancies, within the Department of Health and Wellness, within Municipal Affairs and Housing, within Public Works, Environment and Climate Change, and Naturaal Resources and Renewables - all the departments - did not happen overnight, as well.
I do want to caution - and I don't want to go down the road or the rabbit hole of leaks, documents, and reports - ever so briefly on the report that the government commissioned. The mandate of that report was: How? If government decided to do a Residential Tenancies compliance enforcement unit, how could it look? Not when should it be put in place and how could it be put in place. It was more, what should it look like?
I just want to put those statements on the record, based on feedback that the members have shared this afternoon. Based on - I won't go into where, perhaps, they have found that information. It was noted by my colleague of the NDP, pertaining to renovictions - this was a topic that's been discussed many times in the last couple sessions.
Our government took action to put in a process, recognizing that infrastructure such as apartments and rental properties do have a life expectancy. At times, whether it be a vehicle, a home, roads, or any other piece of infrastructure that we're talking about, there's maintenance to be done, and sometimes that building or that road has to have a big overhaul.
That's why our government took action to put into place a formal process that limits when renovictions can happen. I urge all members of this House to share the information about that process, because at times I've felt that it was being lost and that the members opposite were going to constituents and saying, Tough luck. There's no way out of this. If you get an eviction notice on your door, that's it, that's all. That's not the case.
When a tenant is faced with an eviction notice, they can contest that and submit an application to the program - a program that's designed not to have any legal representation. I understand there are folks who need that extra help, and I know a number of our colleagues here in the House do assist their constituents who have to go through that process.
For the record, since we brought forward those amendments to the Act and proclaimed them - I think it came into force Spring 2022 – there have been 282 applications and 44 applications for renovictions that have taken place. I want to reassure Nova Scotians that the program does work and the process does work.
The member opposite did speak about pet evictions - or evictions pertaining to pets. I've talked about that in the Chamber before. If a landlord decides to change a policy during a lease, again the tenant can and should apply to the program if they disagree with that, at which point the program officer will adjudicate and decide if it is considered reasonable or not reasonable.
In that, there has to be evidence as in any other part of a hearing. Is it reasonable or not reasonable? I don't want to give personal examples, but there could be instances where it is reasonable that a certain animal is causing damage to an apartment, and then that's considered appropriate for certain circumstances. I just want to put that out there.
Bill 412 talks about educating and raising public awareness of landlords' and tenants' rights. I hope that all members of this House, if they haven't already shared information pertaining to the program, that they do. I'm more than happy to share that information. My department is continuing with our education and awareness program because, before you start enforcing something, you have to know the rules.
If I'm a new driver, that's why I have to read the Nova Scotia Driver's Handbook to understand the rules of the road: what certain signs mean and what the speed limits are. It's my responsibility as a driver on the road to know those rules. That's why in a program that we've made, I'd argue, significant changes over the last couple of years, there were a lot of tenants and a lot of landlords who may not be aware of that. That's why we're doing our targeted education awareness campaign online, on social media, and on Google, and that's had high uptake.
We'll continue to do that and we'll continue to work with different organizations - from both tenant and landlord organizations. I've even met with Students Nova Scotia, as part of their awareness week, and offered to work with them to ensure that their folks have access to that information.
Again, pertaining to giving verbal or written warnings to a landlord or a tenant, I don't see such a compliance and enforcement unit being sort of a Wild West where police, as it's referenced in the Act, are patrolling the streets of Nova Scotia to sort of knock on doors and do those types of assessments.
Again, the current program works. It is called a self-referral program - or not referral, but you have to make a complaint. As I've noted earlier, we're taking steps to reduce the wait times. The Premier says more and faster for health care, more and faster for a Residential Tenancies Program, in hearing and wait times. We're working to do that as quickly as possible.
Again, I want to make the point that the silver bullet here for the Residential Tenancies Program is not a compliance and enforcement unit. The challenges we're experiencing today are not going to all be solved by a compliance and enforcement unit. There are issues that are being compounded by the low vacancy rate, and yes, we've seen a high record - the highest record - of new builds last year, but that was dampened a little bit by population growth and newcomers to our province.
I share the sentiment with my colleague, the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing: We welcome newcomers to our province. We need them. We need health care workers. We need skilled tradespeople. We need these people to come to our province to help build up our province. We are a province of opportunity, and as a government, we recognize that potential. As a government, we're ready to support Nova Scotians and implement those solutions that are going to unleash that potential.
The honourable member for Cole Harbour-Dartmouth.
I've enjoyed listening to all sides on this, but it's interesting: I still wear the hat of a municipal councillor for 12 years. What propelled me to run provincially was to help the people in the issues that they deal with day-to-day that the municipality cannot respond to. I'm referring to the calls that we received with regards to landlord issues and tenant issues.
The police often get called. The police are told they can't do anything. Bylaw officers are called. They are told they can't do anything. The people, in their frustration, guess who they call next? Their elected officials.15:30
If there is an awareness campaign, I certainly would like to know about it, because while everyone was speaking, I'm like, Who are they going to call? Who are they supposed to call? No situation is the same, we know that. But for 15 years, I've been discussing and hoping to see a solution to, in that balance, seeing adequate housing provided.
The NDP member spoke about doors falling off and things like that. That's inadequate housing. To have it go before the Residential Tenancies Program is a very long, long process. By the time a door could get fixed, that person is without a roof over their head.
I don't understand the reluctance of the government to actually explore - just explore - what it would possibly look like to have an enforcement unit that would create that balance at arm's length from government, that would support tenants as well as landlords. The government's own consultants said that it was needed. This is the third time that we've tabled this, so that speaks to the very fact of how important we feel that this bill is. We want this government to take it seriously.
Tenant advocates have said that this would be a good thing. Landlords have said that it would be a good thing. The current board and legal aid can't keep up with the demand, and this government needs to do something about it.
We have enforcement to protect the environment. Why don't we have enforcement to protect our rental housing in a tight housing market to balance the rights of the landlords, the property owners, and the tenants? No one seems to know - and I can't tell you how many conversations I've heard from residents over the years asking: Why would I go to the Residential Tenancies Program? They're not going to help me. They've all said it.
I just don't understand why they can't explore the idea. I don't think I would use the rules of the road analogy as a means of supporting not doing anything, because there are a lot of people out there not following those rules - a lot.
It's critical, and we want to grow the population. We've said that. If people in Nova Scotia don't know who to turn to to protect them and give them adequate housing, what about the people who are new to our community and country? Who are they supposed to call? Many of them are living in inadequate housing. That's just not right.
The fact that the government is not willing to even explore what we have seen Ontario and B.C. do - we talk about not reinventing the wheel, but I don't see why you can't just sort of consider it.
On that plea for consideration, I move to adjourn debate on Bill No. 412.
I recognize the motion to adjourn debate on Bill No. 412. Is it agreed?
It is agreed.
All those in favour? Contrary minded? Thank you.
The motion is carried.
The honourable Official Opposition House Leader.
Speaker, the next bill we're going to call is Bill No. 405, the HST Reduction Act.
Bill No. 405 - HST Reduction Act.
The honourable Leader of the Official Opposition.
Our party is advocating to reduce the HST by two points. I'll remind the House that the HST was increased by two points, from 13 per cent to 15 per cent, by the previous NDP government, a government that I served in opposition to as well. That was done at a time of population decline and economic decline in the province. It was done to bring in more revenue to try to keep up with increasing pressures on government services. We are now in a very different circumstance here, Speaker.
We on the Liberal benches really believe that the tax regime in Nova Scotia is regressive, and that it's punitive to people for doing things that we actually want them to be doing. We have gone, in two short years under the Houston government, from being one of the most affordable places to live to one of the most expensive in the country.
Not only have we led the country in increases in rent, which is up 13 per cent this year and 21 per cent the year after, but this is clear evidence that the government's rent cap regime is not working - particularly for anybody new coming into the rental market, either coming in through immigration or young people who are graduating and looking to get out of their parents' houses. We have seen the power rates in this province skyrocket since the NDP were in power as well, back in 2009 to 2013. We are seeing the costs of food, the costs of goods - the necessities of life - and services increase. We have seen the highest increases across the board in many areas in the whole country, and we still have the highest taxes here in Nova Scotia.
What this is doing to people is a very concerning thing. I'm speaking to a fixed-income senior who can't pay their power bills, can't afford their medication, and also can't afford to downsize out of their single-family home because they'll get hit with losing their property tax cap and pay more taxes - if they can even find a place to live that's affordable.
I'm speaking to working-class families that have two incomes coming in to the household who are struggling to make ends meet and feel that they are falling behind financially because of these increased costs that they are experiencing. I'm talking to young people from one end of the province to the other who are actually losing hope in being able to afford a future here. The housing market has become unattainable for them. Life is expensive, and they're wondering whether they are going to be able to have the same quality of life that their parents had here in Nova Scotia, or if they can even stay here and build a life and build a family here.
It's the working-class and middle-class people who fall through the cracks in situations like this, when the cost of living is going up. It's the people whose tax dollars are funding government services, funding income supports, funding specialized grants for those who are financially insecure. It's this group of people who are starting to really struggle here in Nova Scotia. People who are labourers, blue-collar workers, administrative assistants - everybody is feeling the pressure of this moment right now, financially, and it is impacting their quality of life. It's impacting health care outcomes for people, as we see poverty rise, homelessness rise, as well as food insecurity rise in this province.
One way we can provide broad-based relief and financial support to those folks who, again, are paying the bulk of our taxes here in Nova Scotia, is to make sure they're not paying the highest sales tax in the country on the goods and services that they need to survive each and every day. This is not a commitment that we take lightly. We have done the costing on this. We've worked with economists on this. This would cost about half a billion dollars a year.
The savings to the average two-income family home would be about $1,350 a year. That could be two to five power bills that this HST cut would cover. Think of folks who are trying to build new housing units, either in their basements or onto their homes, or to build developments. This is a cut on every single piece of equipment that they would need, all the supplies, and the labour. This is a good policy that we can actually afford to do right now, because this government has had a windfall in taxes and revenues - $3.4 billion dollars in unexpected revenues have been collected by the provincial Treasury over the last two years. The Minister of Finance and Treasury Board was shocked about this - couldn't believe their good fortune. By the way, a lot of that is coming from the federal government that this government enjoys attacking while they take all their cheques and squander them. And $2 billion of that comes from the HST. We are talking about a change to lowering taxes that the Province can actually afford right now. We are not in a period of fiscal decline, population decline, or economic decline - although we'll see if the government manages to change that, because they certainly don't have an economic policy or agenda in this province.
We are talking about taking a fraction of the additional taxes and revenues that have come in and giving that back to people, helping to make life affordable in a really meaningful way each and every day, every time they take their credit card out, every time they take cash out of their pocket to pay for the things that they need to live - food, pet food, sporting equipment, stud wood, plywood, nails - all these things that people are paying the highest taxes for in the country. We can change that - we can afford to change that right now. In fact, I don't think we can afford to not do this.
I am worried about the generational issue that is developing because of the affordability crisis here in this province. Again, we've gone from being one of the most affordable places to live in the country a few short years ago - it wasn't that long ago that the cost of living was low here - to one of the most expensive places to live in the country. We are now rivalling some of the biggest provincial jurisdictions in the country that have had a high cost of living for a long time. - the highest rental increases in the country. Some of the highest power rate increases. People are still paying the highest taxes, and we don't have to pay the highest taxes here anymore.
I will say that this is also a regressive tax. Taxing people on consumer goods is regressive, just like it is to tax income. Think about it: We are punishing people through the tax system for doing things that we actually want them to do. We want them to be more productive. We want them to earn more income. What happens when that happens? Because we are the only province that does not address bracket creep, they lose more money in taxation to the province.
We want people to be consumers. Our economy is driven by consumer behaviour. We are seeing a retraction in consumer spending right now because of the high cost of living. Charging people the highest taxes in the country on consumer goods - the necessities of life - is a regressive thing to do.
This is impacting businesses as well. We have consulted with the CFIB on this. They have done surveys with their membership. Independent small businesses in this province - 50 per cent or more of our economy is driven by these folks. These are the folks who are struggling the most right now to deal with the cost of living. The big corporations are doing fine; many of them are doing better as a result of the current situation. It's the small businesses in each of our communities here in Halifax that are really struggling with the cost increases on the things they have to purchase to do business and on the labour that they have to pay for.
Sales tax is in the top five most harmful costs to small and independent business in this province. They have told us that through surveys - the CFIB has told us that. One of the most harmful taxes in this province to our small business community is the HST, which was increased by the NDP between 2009 and 2013, during a period of decline. We are not in that period anymore. We've seen growth. The government opposite will take credit for that growth even though it happened in the years before, from an economic perspective, with increases in exports and sustainable population growth that wasn't overburdening all our systems and infrastructure.
I know that the government will assert that if we're going to cut taxes, that means the Liberals are going to cut services. That's not true. As I mentioned, we would argue right now that we can afford to do this because of the additional revenues that this government has brought in: $3.4 billion in unexpected additional revenues. It's massive. They suggest that we have to cut things. We don't.
Let's look at where some of this money is going. I really believe that this government is squandering hundreds of millions of dollars to chase headlines and to get political pressure off them to issues manage instead of actually achieving results for people in this province. We see it in health care, where the government pats themselves on the back every single day about how great a job they are doing, while 153,000 people don't have a family doctor, the emergency departments have never been in a worse state, and wait times to see specialists and book MRIs are twice the national average. We see it when they brag about their spending on housing and poverty, while poverty rates and homelessness rates are going up and housing stock isn't keeping pace with the growth of our population.
I want to look at some of the specific spending that this government has done: $464 million in spending to deliver what we were told would be a nursing retention and recruitment bonus - $464 million dollars. We were told that would get 2,000 nurses back into the system. What did it do? One hundred forty-eight nurses; $464 million to increase our net population of nurses by 148 people. Is this good return on investment? The evidence would suggest not.
I think it's going to be up to $80 million on the most expensive hotel that's ever been purchased in this province. The most expensive hotel that's ever been purchased, that was half done, and that according to health care experts couldn't accommodate the health care needs of patients. To put that into perspective, that cost - just at the $50 million level, before the untendered contract was awarded - $735,000 per bed. Is that a good return on investment? Compare that to a hotel that was sold shortly after for a much lower price - that hotel cost $45,000 per bed. Are we getting good returns for our investments? I would argue not.
The apps that we're paying for through untendered contracts - let's look at the Happipad app. Last time I looked, that cost $1.3 million. It achieved 4 leases for people - 4 leases for $1.3 million, $325,000 per lease. What a broker fee that is - in an untendered contract.15:45
Speaker, I cannot allow this government to sit there and say we have to make cuts to services and we can't afford to reduce taxes right now in Nova Scotia, because the evidence suggests we can. The numbers suggest we can - $3.4 billion collected in unexpected revenues.
Because I know the government's going to mention this - the carbon tax. Yes, that has increased the cost of living. Guess who's benefiting the most from that? The provincial government that's charging HST on top of the carbon tax. It's all smoke and mirrors. We have a population that is falling behind financially. We have working-class people who are not making ends meet. We've got a generation of young people coming up who are losing hope of affording a future here. We have a government that so far is turning a blind eye to the real issues that matter - the real cost pressures on people - like paying the highest taxes in the country on their hard-earned income and on the purchase of every single good and item they need to survive and live.
We are in a position right now to provide financial relief to Nova Scotians, whether it's a fixed-income senior, a working family, or a young person who's going to be trying to make ends meet, find a place to live, and get by here in Nova Scotia. We've got an opportunity right now. If this government moves and supports this motion, this piece of legislation to cut the HST, we can start doing that important work of making life more affordable here. We can start doing that important work of supporting those working-class people and those middle-class families who are struggling as hard as anybody else right now in this province. If we move on this, young people who are going to be coming up into our workforce - we can ensure that they have a more affordable life here as they pay less and less for all the things they need to live. We can do that if we have some vision from this government, if they move this bill and reduce the cost of taxes to Nova Scotians and help make life more affordable here.
The honourable member for Halifax Citadel-Sable Island.
We welcome the opportunity this afternoon to talk about the cost of living challenges that Nova Scotians across this province are facing and the ways that this government could be - but isn't - helping.
The costs of all essentials have been rapidly rising - everything from power and food to fuel and housing. Everyone is feeling the pinch. The cost of groceries increased over 6 per cent last year and 13 per cent the year before. Last year's Food Banks Canada Report Card noted that 53 per cent of people in Nova Scotia feel that they are worse off than they were a year ago. This is a higher percentage than in any other province.
Power rates have increased 13.6 per cent in 2 years, and families are struggling to make ends meet. We agree that people need a break. That's why we've been putting forward ideas for years to help average Nova Scotian families facing rising housing costs, food costs, energy costs, and with wages that just aren't keeping up. Ideas like removing unnecessary vehicle fees - the renewal sticker, for instance - or rent control and other renter protections.
We've been advocating for a living wage, so that people are able to afford the necessities of life. We've advocated for free birth control and free menstrual products. We've advocated for low-income power rates and to ban power disconnections. We want to expand the HomeWarming Program and we want to end pharmacare co-payments. All of these are things that can be done so quickly by this government.
We want a universal school food program. We've suggested increasing and indexing the Affordable Living Tax Credit. We want a seniors income benefit, the likes of which every other jurisdiction aside from P.E.I. has in this country, where seniors are not expected to apply year after year. We want paid sick days, and to stop tip theft. We want to increase and index HARP. We want to ensure that programs and investments have a gender lens, and take into account the potential and needs of our diverse communities, our Indigenous and African Nova Scotian communities, 2SLGBTQIA+ folks, and newcomer populations.
That's why we've been talking for a while now about cutting the HST entirely off all grocery products. Again, folks, this is a quick and easy change that would make a big difference for Nova Scotians. It's why the Nova Scotia NDP government removed all provincial tax off family essentials - including children's clothing, footwear, diapers - and all provincial tax off power bills and home heating. This is all because we believe that Nova Scotians trying to afford the essentials need a break from increasing costs.
The Liberals were unsupportive of these measures. It wasn't that long ago that Stephen McNeil voted against taking the HST off power bills and home heating. In fact, the Liberals voted eight times to tax home heating and energy. I think many Nova Scotians like us are skeptical of these big promises Liberals make in Opposition. The Liberals have been promising a gas tax cut since 2009, and despite eight years in government with Zach Churchill in Cabinet, this never happened.
Order. You can't use members' names. I ask that you refer to them by their title.
The honourable member for Halifax Citadel-Sable Island.
I apologize. Thank you for the reminder. Despite eight years in government, the Leader of the Official Opposition was in Cabinet, this never happened. Why would Nova Scotians trust him on this? I would like to table that.
We're also skeptical about the math that Liberals are using here. Estimating that people will save $650 per year is based on the false presumption that we all spend equally. Those with more disposable income will spend more, and will therefore benefit more than others from an HST cut. A cut to the HST will give more money to people buying luxury goods than the families who deserve the break.
We heard some of the pushback after this was announced last month. Lori Turnbull, the director of the School of Public Administration and an associate professor of political science at Dalhousie University, said that this plan to cut HST is unlikely to have a major impact on the affordability crisis in the province, and that it could be seen as missing the mark to give something to people who largely don't really need it, and put the province at risk of not being able to provide the same level of service. I'll table that as well.
We heard last month from the Liberal Leader that people need to eat, people need clothes, people need phones, people need the internet - and we agree. We propose that no groceries should be taxed. Children's clothes already don't have the provincial tax on them at all. We could also be looking into removing the provincial tax from other essential services and products, the way the New Democrats did on power bills, which would help more people more directly.
I also want to highlight the reality that sales tax is a massive revenue generator for our province, last year bringing in $2.3 billion in revenue. Revenue loss at this scale is undeniably going to mean cuts somewhere else. I'm curious where the Liberals are proposing these cuts to take place. Do they want to cut spending on health care? Housing? How would this revenue loss impact our ability to create a universal school food program, our ability to hire more family doctors, or build enough affordable housing? We're looking to the Liberals to explain what they're hoping to accomplish here.
Our caucus is in favour of increasing affordability for Nova Scotians, but we recognize that not all Nova Scotians are in similar positions. The measures that the Liberals are proposing would disproportionately benefit those with higher incomes, and disproportionately disadvantage those in the middle class and those with lower incomes.
There's lots to do that can help Nova Scotians who need it most, but cutting the HST isn't one of them.
The honourable member for Kings West.
I am very honoured, as always, to rise again in the House today to speak on Bill No. 405. I could just say that I echo everything that the member for Halifax Citadel-Sable Island said, but I will expand on a few things.
I would like to say, Speaker, that Nova Scotians want their governments to be responsible. They want them to have a balanced approach when it comes to spending the public purse. They know that they want their government to address a lot of the services and the government initiatives that are important to them. That's why I'm proud to be part of this government. This government knows that it is truly important to recognize the fiscal responsibility while at the same time addressing the needs that people have. We want to be good stewards of the financial purse.
We were very upfront with Nova Scotians when we came to power. We told them that after years of neglect of spending in health care, after years of neglect in spending in long-term care, after years of neglect in spending in our roads and infrastructure, after years of neglect in spending in housing, that it was time to catch up. We were very upfront with them, and we told them that we would have to invest in those programs to give them the services that they truly deserved, and Nova Scotians have been responding to that.
I think it's important to understand the implications of what reducing the HST by 2 per cent would have, and the impact it would have on Nova Scotians. As has been mentioned, the decrease in HST revenue would equate to a projected loss of about $500 million, jeopardizing the sustainability of critical government programs.
I would like to maybe ask a few questions here. I know it's been mentioned that we always want to look at fiscal responsibility and have a chance to pay less in taxes. Who doesn't want to pay less in taxes? Everyone wants to do that, right? But if I had to go back to the people I represent - go to the Village of Greenwood, for example - and say, you know, the investment in your community in lighting around Civic Field that is going to give the residents of that community extended hours for recreational use, and investment in their trail system - if I had to go back to them and say, well, I don't think we can do that now because we've had to reduce the HST by 2 per cent, I'd have a hard time doing that. I don't think they would appreciate that.
My wife, for example, is an X-ray tech at Soldiers Memorial Hospital. If I had to go to my wife and say that we can't do important investments in infrastructure and diagnostic imaging at Soldiers Memorial Hospital right now because we had to cut the HST by 2 per cent, I don't want to tell my wife that. Maybe the member opposite would like to do that, but I'm not going to tell my wife that.
I have a community of people who've been lobbying for a brand new long-term care place in Berwick - Grandview Manor. If I had to go back to the community I represent and say, sorry, we had to reduce the HST by 2 per cent, so we can't get those 144 single units to give your mother and your grandmother dignity, that wouldn't be good.
I had the privilege of having 5.5 kilometres of the No. 1 Highway through Aylesford last year. If I had to go to the people I represent in Aylesford and all through my community and say, you know what, I can't get those 5.5 kilometres of road for you this year because we had to cut the HST by 2 per cent, that wouldn't go over very well. Would it go over very well?Interruptions No, it wouldn't.16:00
We're looking at investing in the Town of Berwick with infrastructure spending that's going to help with their wastewater improvements. If I had to go back to the Town of Berwick and say, sorry, we can't make that investment in your community because we had to cut the HST by 2 per cent, that wouldn't go over very well, would it?
The Cambridge Interchange, for example. We have a proposal - a development on the Cambridge Interchange - that's going to provide access from the Waterville Michelin plant right out to the highway. It's going to save the No. 1 Highway lots of wear and tear. If I had to go back to the people that we represent and say, sorry, we can't have that Cambridge Interchange anymore because we had to cut the HST by 2 per cent. That wouldn't go over very well either.
If I had to go back to a lot of the strawberry producers I represent and visited with the Minister of Agriculture and say, well, a lot of the environmental issues you had last year around crop damage because of flooding, sorry, tough luck, there's nothing for you because we had to cut the HST by 2 per cent, that wouldn't go over very well in my community either.
There's another section of Highway No. 1 that's going to be coming through Coldbrook where the members from Kings South and Kings North represent. If they had to go back to their constituents and say, sorry, we can't get that Highway No. 1 paved this Summer because we had to cut the HST, that wouldn't go over very well either.
I just highlighted a few of those things, and here we are on a day where we just had announcements of the most generational investments in diabetes care. I am proud to be part of a government that put that in place. If we had to say to those families, sorry, we can't do it, we had to cut the HST by 2 per cent, what kind of responsible government are we really being?
There are lots of ways this government is addressing affordability. We understand the concerns and the issues that Nova Scotians are facing right now, but they also want us to be real. They want us to be responsible. They want balance.
Let's talk about the Seniors Care Grant for a second, which assists our vulnerable residents by providing funding for things like health care services for your health and wellness like foot care, physiotherapy, and mental health support; home heating like furnace oil, natural gas, propane, firewood, wood pellets, and electricity; home heating repairs, and regular heating maintenance; home cleaning; organizing when helping with downsizing and moving. Is this a program that we really want to cut because we cut the HST 2 per cent?
The Province also administers HST rebates for the provincial portion of the HST on home heating, and it's important to note that is only the provincial part that is not there. The federal government still has their portion of the HST on home heating. Maybe our members across the aisle want to lobby the federal government in eliminating that as well for Nova Scotians.
We have a First-time Home Buyers' Rebate. We have rebates for personal items like children's clothing and printed books. To increase housing supply, the Province recently announced it will provide a rebate for the provincial portion of the HST for multi-unit, purpose-built rental housing in Nova Scotia. These are all things we're doing to help Nova Scotians in tax relief.
We're also looking at the More Opportunities for Skilled Trades program we put in place. That is a program helping so many Nova Scotians under the age of 30. They're working in the trades. Originally that was a program that was just going to be people in the skilled trades, but this government realized that it was an important incentive to keep people in this province, so we increased that tax rebate on the first $50,000 of income to not just the skilled trades, but to nurses. We expanded it to the film industry, which is growing in our province. A little reminder that the previous government cut film incentive programs. This government is bringing them back, and they're coming back to this province to produce films in their droves.
These programs that I've outlined help many, many thousands of Nova Scotians. I don't know if the Opposition would want to cut anything from the health care budget. No. They didn't do anything to really improve health care when they were in government. Maybe if we looked at things like our investments in CCAs. Could we go back to CCAs and say, "Sorry, we can't give you a big wage increase because we had to cut the HST by 2 per cent?"
Speaker, we know that Nova Scotians realize they want a responsible, balanced government, and that's exactly what they're getting from this government right now. It's important for long-term financial planning to the Province that it has a stable revenue source. It is crucial to acknowledge the revenue raised through the HST. This is the second largest provincial revenue source, which our government uses to support programs and services. These are important programs and services that residents of Nova Scotia rely on.
Our budget will be released tomorrow, you may have heard. I'm sure it will contain even more measures to assist hard-working Nova Scotians. These are the people our government continues to invest in.
My parents told me that money doesn't grow on trees. And maybe the folks across the aisle, maybe they didn't get that same lesson. But I think if money doesn't come in, money can't go out, so it can't go to those programs that Nova Scotians want and need. They ask us to be good financial stewards of the purse. They ask us to be responsible; they ask us to be balanced. They ask us to be prudent with their dollar and be accountable.
Money the government receives from the HST is fundamental in sustaining essential services, and reducing the HST wouldn't just affect existing programs, it would also hinder our ability to finance future initiatives that benefit Nova Scotians all over the place. This is the future of our children and our grandchildren. I don't want to go home and tell the residents of Kings West that we are no longer willing to support all those projects I mentioned earlier. And I don't think members across the aisle would want to do that in their constituencies either.
There's only one government, let's be clear, that has introduced a punishing consumer tax in Nova Scotia. That is the carbon tax. During this time of inflation and one of the biggest affordability crises of our time, the federal government launched a punishing consumer tax on the people of Nova Scotia.
I look across the aisle and ask, "Are they standing up to their federal cousins and fighting for our residents who are suffering?" If the member opposite would like to table a bill titled, A Bill to Lobby the Prime Minister to Get Rid of the Carbon Tax, we might be willing to support that. (Laughter and applause)
On this side of the aisle, we remain dedicated to ensuring the well-being and prosperity of our Province, now and for future generations. The member opposite, he says that this is the time when we can explore a reduction in the HST. Well, I guess the eight years when he was in government, that was never the time. It's a little disingenuous to believe that now he thinks this is the time.
Speaker, to conclude, I'd like to again say that it is important to acknowledge the role played by the HST. This is the second largest provincial revenue source, which our government uses to support our programs and services. HST rebates allocated to the public sector, charitable organizations and individuals are fundamental in sustaining essential services and improving the life of Nova Scotians.
I would like to say that it might be time. There is a lot more we are going to be doing, but I have full confidence in our Premier. I have full confidence in the Minister of Finance and Treasury Board, and I believe the people of Nova Scotia have the full confidence of their Premier and their Minister of Finance and Treasury Board to administer the finances of this province, and we'll continue to do that in a responsible and accountable manner. We want to thank everybody out there for continuing to put their support in our government.